So 'hypothetically' what could happen if your desktop fell off the desk?

Grimezy

Prolific Poster
So as the title says... hypothetically, if one was to own a creature such as... oh I don't know, a 7 month old cat... And say you had your desktop set up on a desk which is about 3 foot off the floor. And say that cat decided to use the rig to jump 6 feet into the air onto a nearby wardrobe at 5am this morning, and then couldn't get down so decided to jump back down by aiming for your desktop only to hear it crash to the ground and land upside down in what can only be described as a kamikaze strike.

Hypothetically what sort of damage could this have done? Assuming that the person that this has happened to had inspected the damage and could only visually see a section of plastic chip off the top. And assuming the person had booted it up to check everything was okay and it seemed to boot fine other than the screen flashing black once while logging in which has never happened before but didn't seem too alarming. And assuming they hadn't had chance to open it up and look inside it this morning to make sure everything was in order as they were too god damn tired and had to go to work, what should they look out for when they get home? Is it just the standard procedure like make sure the ram is still seated and nothing has cracked anywhere?

And could they prevent this in the future? I'd assume they would want to continue having the rig on the desk as they wouldn't want it to be on a dusty carpet floor but would there be any other way around it? Locking the hypothetical cat out of the room wouldn't really be an option as he'd soon destroy the carpet outside the door... if this was a real scenario. Would having the rig on the carpet really be that bad? Hypothetically it would make the desk look a lot more spacious.

So yea, what are your guys thoughts and hypothetically how much damage could a 3 foot fall cause to say... a Coolermaster CM690 II Advanced? I'd assume that a normal boot up straight after it would be a good sign if this had really happened.

Please note: This scenario is completely fictional and should not be used against the thread starter as evidence against if he should be granted an RMA or not for any potential damage this hypothetical situation may have caused.
 

SmokeDarKnight

Author Level
Think i'd be claiming it off my household insurance although you probably wouldn't mention the animal part as I'm sure that there is a clause about Animal damage not being covered, however, hypothetically if the desk it was on collapsed and the desktop fell off the edge i guess that would be a reason for a claim. Also i think if the desktop was over the value of about £1200 i think it has to be declared prior to the claim

To prevent it you could probibly build some sort of frame for it to stop it moving, some no more nails as an extreme.

I think most of the damage would be cosmetic and any internal damage would be loose items that have movement on them may cause cracks, i.e. a GPU only secured from one side.
 
Last edited:

kruppsy

Master
Cat pie?...

But I imagine if nothing is visible, no weird rattles or grating noises rear their head and the thing boots and runs ok, you should be fine, just check everything is still seated ok.....sorry, not you...someone, anyone, with that hypothetical scenario...

I think the hypothetical person could buy a little booster tray thing that gets the case off the carpet by an inch or so. I got one with a desk, but im sure they're available separately.

Phew...sidestepped a few potential landmines there...
 
Last edited:

DeadEyeDuk

Superhero Level Poster
No way! This happened to me last night too!

That's actually a complete lie...I hate cats :)


If it is broken, just "pull a Joey" and have the case teetering rather dangerously on your desk and push a nearby loved one or friend into it and then claim they broke it so they pay for it! :) Too far? Ok...
 

dogbot

Bright Spark
Short of actually throwing my cat at the PC I would say that the PC is very heavy whereas the cat is relatively light and agile. It is not likely to budge your PC.

Assuming it did fall to the floor for some obscure reason, I don't think a carpet would cause external marking but the weight of the PC might cause some distortion of the case. In particular, some items in the PC might become dislodged such as the graphics card or connections.

I suppose you could bolt it to the desk but personally I have mine on the floor where it is out of the way but the DVD drive and front loading caddy easily accessible.
 

DeadEyeDuk

Superhero Level Poster
I have a colony of spiders that live in the gap between the desk and wall that protect my PC from any foreign pets or children. They are tasked with attacking on site and asking questions later. I'm slightly concerned that they are going to get organised and join a union, but until then I shall continue to have them work for free, although I do offer excellent dental support...

...
 

Grimezy

Prolific Poster
Short of actually throwing my cat at the PC I would say that the PC is very heavy whereas the cat is relatively light and agile. It is not likely to budge your PC.

Assuming it did fall to the floor for some obscure reason, I don't think a carpet would cause external marking but the weight of the PC might cause some distortion of the case. In particular, some items in the PC might become dislodged such as the graphics card or connections.

I suppose you could bolt it to the desk but personally I have mine on the floor where it is out of the way but the DVD drive and front loading caddy easily accessible.

I had the same philosophy when coming up with my hypothetical situation, "how can a tiny cat topple a case that big", etc etc. Unfortunately I had not taken into account the velocity that the cat could gain from jumping from a 6-7foot high structure, down about 3 feet and across about 1.5metres and not landing perfectly light footed on top of the case. I believe there may have been a backwards thrust of the legs involved as he overshot his jump causing the rig to topple sideways.

I personally am very concerned with this hypothetical scenario as I actually only started using a conventional desk setup a week ago and whether to put my rig on the floor or desk had been a tricky decision. I opted to put it on the desk to increase airflow but after conjuring up this hypothetical scenario I do worry that my cat could somehow do to me what the fictional cat did to the fictional computer owner so now I'm thinking the floor would be the best place for my machine.
 

mishra

Rising Star
I would:
- boot up and listen carefully for any rattly noises (aka damage to fans)
- boot up PC, install HD Tune (free) and check if HDDs are OK, by doing full scan
- monitor my temps, to see if all is fine

... if all above seems fine, then forget about the problem, just make sure it wont happen again.
 

ubuysa

The BSOD Doctor
I'm confused, is the cat hypothetical or the desktop PC? Or both? And is the desktop hypothetically running or powered-off? If the former I'd be very concerned about HDD damage... :confused:

I would open the case up before powering back on and check that everything is where it should be, that no plugs have come loose and that all cards are properly seated. I'd also give the power supply a very close look too.

Then I'd boot it and enter the BIOS to select the maximal POST. On OS boot I'd be listening for any clicks, grinds or rattles.

Then I'd probably do a surface scan of the HDDs just to be on the safe side.

Then I'd probably get rid of the cat...... :shifty:
 

Flucky

Well-known member
That's actually a complete lie...I hate cats :)

Even with a SlurpyJ voiceovers?
(Sorry for the video dump)

[video=youtube_share;1L5EixUCpuk]http://youtu.be/1L5EixUCpuk[/video] [video=youtube_share;CSK1D3bZhRs]http://youtu.be/CSK1D3bZhRs[/video][video=youtube_share;aT4XdWuwoNs]http://youtu.be/aT4XdWuwoNs[/video] [video=youtube_share;1JynBEX_kg8]http://youtu.be/1JynBEX_kg8[/video]


(Actually I'm not very sorry at all)
 

Rakk

The Awesome
Moderator
Then I'd probably do a surface scan of the HDDs just to be on the safe side.

Yeah, I killed the HDD in a work PC by accidently knocking it over and it wasn't even on a desk, it was on the floor (well I couldnt of accidentally kicked it over if it had been on the desk - and it was one of those small thin cases that was easy to knock over) - it wasn't til the next day or so that it died, after I turned it on I tried to open IE (yes, I know IE is evil, but it was the only browser I had on the machine at the time), and the PC hung (no auto-restart, no bsod, had to hit the power button), did this a few times, luckily I got all the relevant data off onto the network, cos when we did a scandisk it hung half way through - thats how you can really tell your HDD is screwed :)
 
Top