PSA: AMD AM5 issue with over voltage requiring BIOS update

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
Yeah thinking the same, already sent them a mail yesterday so have to do an RMA I suppose. Shame to have to go through it but have to get it sorted out.

Nobody's fault, not sure their testing would have caught this since it seems to only happen when I try launch a game and everything else to that point works just fine. Just odd that even after I restart the machine it still has issues even trying to get into windows and needs a full Windos reinstall to fix it. It's like the crash corrupts the whole system. Very odd.
 

Scott

Behold The Ford Mondeo
Moderator
It sounds like a memory issue to me. It's the sort of issues that you will get with unstable RAM.

It's already been noted that the latest BIOS updates can actually make stock RAM unstable when it requires more voltage than the stock settings allow. EXPO can rectify this but not until it's sorted out. It's a bit of a catch 22 situation so I would let PCS work it out.
 

Scott

Behold The Ford Mondeo
Moderator
So I wait 9 days for permission to flash my BIOS and it's likely to start causing more problems? :mad: Starting to think I'll just leave EXPO off and wait 6 months before considering a BIOS update, especially given my system is working fine

It's a tricky situation mate. Without the bios update the voltage can still over shoot and cause hardware degredation. You won't notice this in performance.

Installing the bios should reduce the over voltage issues, but in doing so can hamstring the RAM if it's not a good enough bin of chips.

From what I understand so far 1403 doesn't actually fix the problem, it still over shoots on the voltage. This will be better for compatibility but a danger for longevity (with EXPO). I saw 1.24v locked on the SoC which was fine for my uses. Some RAM needs 1.3 for stability though and no matter what I set mine to it stayed at 1.24v.

If your SoC is registering less than 1.3v and you have stability then I would just leave it for now.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
It sounds like a memory issue to me. It's the sort of issues that you will get with unstable RAM.

It's already been noted that the latest BIOS updates can actually make stock RAM unstable when it requires more voltage than the stock settings allow. EXPO can rectify this but not until it's sorted out. It's a bit of a catch 22 situation so I would let PCS work it out.
I tried disabling CPB to see if it was maybe a processor issue but same thing.

Starting to think it's possibly the graphics card.

In any case too many maybes so will RMA it.

Just got unlucky, it happens!
 

Scott

Behold The Ford Mondeo
Moderator
My SoC doesn't even register as high as 1.1v! At least not on minimal use...I haven't checked it under load but I can't imagine it would shift that much

I wouldn't be overly concerned then, that seems fine to me. You've got a ton of performance left on the table but until this is all ironed out I would just hold off.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
You could always check that by removing the graphics card and plugging the monitor into the motherboard...the 7800x3D has integrated graphics(assuming you haven't disabled them in the BIOS of course)
Was thinking that but if it is faulty then it's going back for RMA anyway and if it's not faulty it's still going back for RMA!

I'll let them check it out and replace the card if needed. Really don't want to break something by accident (I've changed cards before but when it's under warranty no point risking it).
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
So ASUS have removed the warranty bit on all the latest published Beta BIOS for their boards, seems the pressure is getting through to them.
 

sck451

MOST VALUED CONTRIBUTOR
So ASUS have removed the warranty bit on all the latest published Beta BIOS for their boards, seems the pressure is getting through to them.
Or, following Hanlon's razor, this was always the intention but in rushing to get it delivered, not all the ducks were neatly in their rows.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
So one thing I did not check is the type of RAM installed.

It's listed as (2 x 16gb) 6000mhz CL 40-40-40-77

I checked and none of the Corsair AMD RAM has this spec. It seems this is Corsair RAM designed for Intel systems.

Would this cause the issues I'm seeing or does it not really matter?
 

SpyderTracks

We love you Ukraine
So one thing I did not check is the type of RAM installed.

It's listed as (2 x 16gb) 6000mhz CL 40-40-40-77

I checked and none of the Corsair AMD RAM has this spec. It seems this is Corsair RAM designed for Intel systems.

Would this cause the issues I'm seeing or does it not really matter?
So long as it's got XMP applied and not EXPO it should be fine.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
It is using EXPO..it's the same with mine. Corsair don't list my RAM at all (might be the same RAM as you), not even if I search for the model name...Crucial don't recognise it as Corsair RAM but HWInfo and CPU-Z both do.

It shouldn't be related to the issue you are having as mine has been stable with EXPO turned on and with EXPO turned off

View attachment 36991
Thanks for the info, looks like we have the exact same RAM so if it's working on your AM5 board then it should work on mine. Looking more likely it's faulty RAM but will do the RMA and get it sorted.

How is your new system on the whole? Was really impressed with speed and the FPS (for the few minutes I was able to see them!) on mine.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
I love my new system, RGB overload and all (was never a fan of RGB before...then I bought a system with RGB everything lol). I was gaming on a Series X console on a 4k TV and wanted to play games using the full 120Hz of my TV (as no games on the Series X currently allow that) and my system has not disappointed....unsurprising given it's got a 4090 in it.
Yeah a 4090 will eat up a 4k setting!

I'm on a 1440p monitor (have a 4k TV for certain games on big screen). Went for the 6950XT. Price has plummeted on it so couldn't resist the bang for the buck. Hopefully get to give it a proper run soon depending on how long the RMA process is.
 

SpyderTracks

We love you Ukraine
It is using EXPO..it's the same with mine. Corsair don't list my RAM at all (might be the same RAM as you), not even if I search for the model name...Crucial don't recognise it as Corsair RAM but HWInfo and CPU-Z both do.

It shouldn't be related to the issue you are having as mine has been stable with EXPO turned on and with EXPO turned off

View attachment 36991
RAM is silicon, hence your bound by the same silicon lottery as if you were overclocking a CPU.

One DIMM will have entirely different voltage capabilities to another, and a difference of 10mV from an EXPO pre applied OC to an Intel XMP could mean the difference between stability and BSODs. This is exactly why it's so important to buy matched pairs, because they're likely from the same wafer and therefor have similar electical properties.

Saying "it works fine on mine" is a bit like saying take my glasses, I can see fine so you should be able to.

The Intel RAM DIMMS do not have any EXPO profiles loaded on the DIMM itself, so it's not tying in correctly with the OC profiles on the Mobo.

EXPO DIMMS will normally have a few XMP profiles loaded additionally to the EXPO ones.

I would still suggest using XMP if you don't have EXPO RAM as the voltage parameters are designed for that DIMM.
 
Last edited:

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
RAM is silicon, hence your bound by the same silicon lottery as if you were overclocking a CPU.

One DIMM will have entirely different voltage capabilities to another, and a difference of 10mV from an EXPO pre applied OC to an Intel XMP could mean the difference between stability and BSODs. This is exactly why it's so important to buy matched pairs, because they're likely from the same wafer and therefor have similar electical properties.

Saying "it works fine on mine" is a bit like saying take my glasses, I can see fine so you should be able to.

The Intel RAM DIMMS do not have any EXPO profiles loaded on the DIMM itself, so it's not tying in correctly with the OC profiles on the Mobo.

EXPO DIMMS will normally have a few XMP profiles loaded additionally to the EXPO ones.

I would still suggest using XMP if you don't have EXPO RAM as the voltage parameters are designed for that DIMM.
So on my BIOS (when I got the system) it had EXPO Enabled on the main page. In the advanced settings under the AI Tweaker it was set to "Auto" which I assume knows the capability of your RAM and sets to either EXPO or XMP.

Odd thing is the timings on my RAM (checking in Task Manager) were around 5800 and not 6000.

After disabling EXPO (again, just on the main BIOS page as it's worded that way) the RAM clocked down to 4800 and still had issues.
 

LeeB

Bronze Level Poster
I know it likely won't make a difference but might change it from Auto to XMP and see if it works as it will likely change settings to optimise for that (even though Auto should technically do that).
 

SpyderTracks

We love you Ukraine
So on my BIOS (when I got the system) it had EXPO Enabled on the main page. In the advanced settings under the AI Tweaker it was set to "Auto" which I assume knows the capability of your RAM and sets to either EXPO or XMP.

Odd thing is the timings on my RAM (checking in Task Manager) were around 5800 and not 6000.

After disabling EXPO (again, just on the main BIOS page as it's worded that way) the RAM clocked down to 4800 and still had issues.
You're right, if you're still getting instability with EXPO off then it's nothing to do with either XMP or EXPO.

I would run a Memtest86 run on both DIMMS from a bootable USB

Can you upload a screenshot of your optional updates page?
 

Scott

Behold The Ford Mondeo
Moderator
You're right, if you're still getting instability with EXPO off then it's nothing to do with either XMP or EXPO.

I would run a Memtest86 run on both DIMMS from a bootable USB

Can you upload a screenshot of your optional updates page?

This is the weird behaviour that Jayz2cents had. With EXPO and XMP off, the system would BSOD as the stock settings weren't feeding the RAM enough voltage. Ended up in that rock and hard place scenario where with EXPO off, it wouldn't post. But with it on, it would... but lose warranty.
 

SpyderTracks

We love you Ukraine
This is the weird behaviour that Jayz2cents had. With EXPO and XMP off, the system would BSOD as the stock settings weren't feeding the RAM enough voltage. Ended up in that rock and hard place scenario where with EXPO off, it wouldn't post. But with it on, it would... but lose warranty.
Oh, I thought that was with EXPO on, didn't realise it was affecting him with it off.
 
Top